In the Mouth of Madness (1995)
The arcane and esoteric works of author H P Lovecraft have often inspired horror directors. Sadly many of the films that have been made in homage to the Cthulhu Mythos have failed to capture its nightmarish mix of madness and mythology. John Carpenter's In the Mouth of Madness is not directly based on any of Lovecraft's specific works but screenwriter Michael De Luca draws his inspiration from many of this recurring ideas and concepts. He then adds a further homage to British writer Nigel Kneale, adding themes that are prevalent in his Quatermass series. Where others have failed, Carpenter successfully crafts a film that alludes to the baroque and eldritch qualities of the Cthulhu Mythos.
In the Mouth of Madness begins with John Trent (Sam Neill), an insurance investigator who has recently been "sectioned", telling his story to the resident psychiatrist. Hired to track down horror author Sutter Cane by his publishers, Trent finds the trail leads him to the town of Hobb's End. This is poses a perplexing problem as the town is fictional and shouldn't exist outside of the Cane’s novels. Using a hidden map on the cover of Cane’s book, Trent travels to Hobb’s End and watches the town collapse into madness, murder and monstrous transformations: the contents of Cane's novels manifesting in the material world. Furthermore this blight wants to spread! The dark forces working through Cane's text have designs to engulf the entire world.
In the Mouth of Madness is a surprising return to form by Carpenter during a time when his film making was very hit or miss. It is thoughtful, minimalist and has the brooding traits of a Lovecraft story along with the "science versus the ancient world" themes common in Kneale's work. There is clever imagery, some radical plot twists and a lot of black humour. However this is not a gorefest and the emphasis is on atmosphere and performances to create a disturbing tale. Sam Neil drives the narrative forward with a compelling lead performance. The viewer needs to watch very closely because the devil is very much in the detail leading to a thought provoking climax.
Overlooked at the box office, In the Mouth of Madness improves greatly with a second viewing. It's more an eerie vignette and a cunning critique of the horror genre, than a traditional horror. It’s not designed to shock or terrify, preferring to build a sense of disquiet. The cast such as David Warner and Jürgen Prochnow are well versed in the genre. The production design and physical effects are perfect for the tone of the film. This is very much a movie that leaves the viewer reflecting upon what they have seen. Certainly for those who are more patient and disposed towards the thoughtful, it's a rewarding experience. But that’s hardly surprising because John Carpenter’s work on a bad day (which this movie is not) is always more interesting than many of his peers on a good one.
