In 1937, while on holiday in Cornwall, London music critic and composer Roderick "Rick" Fitzgerald (Ray Milland) and his sister Pamela (Ruth Hussey) discover Windward House, an abandoned clifftop home. They decide to see if they can buy it from its current owner Commander Beech (Donald Crisp). He willingly settles for an unusually low price of £1,200. Rick and Pamela meet Beech's 20-year-old granddaughter Stella Meredith (Gail Russell), who lives with her grandfather after her parents death. Stella is strongly attached to the house, and its sale upsets her. Although Stella’s mother, Mary Meredith, fell to her death from the cliffs outside Windward House seventeen years earlier, Stella reflects fondly on her time there as a child. Commander Beech forbids Stella from going to Windward House, but Rick and Pamela feel sorry for Stella and indulge her visits. However, shortly after moving in Pamela and then Rick become aware of drafts on the staircase, cold spots in the studio room and ghostly weeping in the night.