Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (2019)
Two years ago The Last Jedi was released to mixed reviews. A vocal percentage of fans complained bitterly about various aspects of the movie. Some of their assertions such as the episodic pacing of parts of the story had merit. While other criticisms regarding diversity and gender categorically did not. However, Disney were cognisant of the fact that Star Wars fans were not universally enthralled by the movie although it turned a healthy profit. And then the following Easter Solo “underperformed” at the box office and journalists started talking about how the franchise had overreached itself and was in decline. Alarm bells obviously went off at board level and something had to be done. It would appear that The Rise of Skywalker is very much a movie designed to put the franchise back on track and wrap up the narrative proceedings of the last 42 years. However, there is a cost in offering such a colossal “fan service”. The latest instalment starts at a breakneck pace and continues in that idiom for over two hours. Action scenes, canonical references and homages are piled on, one after another. But narratively things are somewhat thin, recycling ideas and concepts from earlier movies. Some of the plot devices are never explained and therefore seem somewhat contrived. The Rise of Skywalker is most certainly entertaining. But it requires its core audience to be forgiving and to a degree complicit in its indulgences and failings.
If you have seen any of the marketing and advertising material associated with The Rise of Skywalker, then you will already know one of the key plot points of the film. Emperor Palpatine survived the destruction of the second Death Star and is “recovering” on the Sith home world of Exegol. When tracked down and confronted by Kylo Ren, Palpatine reveals that he was behind the creation of the First order and manipulated Supreme Leader Snoke. The Emperor then offers Ren a secret fleet of Star Destroyers along with complete control of the galaxy, if he hunts down and kills Rey. Meanwhile, a spy within the First Order informs the Resistance of Kylo Ren’s activities. Rey, Poe, Finn and Chewbacca subsequently embark on a search for Exogel, using Luke Skywalker’s notes on Jedi texts. Will Kylo Ren carry out the Emperor’s wishes and betray Rey? Will Rey give in to the dark side of the force and discover her true destiny? Will the Resistance fight alone or will the oppressed citizens of the galaxy rise up and fight the First Order in one final struggle?
The Rise of Skywalker is a finely tooled but somewhat arbitrary conclusion to the Star Wars franchise. Director J. J. Abrams turns the action and pacing up to eleven, offering a cavalcade of digital set pieces and bombastic spectacles. The weightier plot elements raised by The Last Jedi have been jettisoned in favour of action, melodrama and keeping core fans happy. Where Rian Johnson reflected upon the hubris of the Jedi and how they were the architects of their own demise, Abrams is more content to shoehorn in as many cameos possible into the movies 142-minute running time. Furthermore, the object lesson that General Leia taught Poe Dameron about the nature of command, which was so well written by Rian Johnson, has now been forgotten in this instalment. Poe has reverted back to a headstrong character who rashly rushes into situations. The film parallels several iconic scenes from both The Empire Strikes Back and Return of the Jedi. It is debatable as to whether this is a cunning plot device showing history between Jedi and Sith repeating itself, or whether it is simply lazy writing designed to get the story out of the corner it has painted itself into.
As you would expect with this franchise, the quality of the production is outstanding. The scope of many of the digital action scenes are breath taking and there is also a lot of great physical effects and old school stunt work. As ever the Star Wars universe looks and feels very credible and lived in. Yes, the science behind many ideas is way off base but that was never what this series was about. Star Wars has always been and remains science fantasy and high adventure, as opposed to pure science fiction. Dan Mindel’s cinematography is very creative and often it’s the minor attention to detail that makes a scene. For example, there’s a wonderful reverse tracking shot where Poe and Finn advance along a corridor picking off Stormtroopers who fall dead, into the frame. The obvious physical humour of the previous movie has gone and the emphasis is once again on dry quips and asides. This is much more like A New Hope and is far less of a distraction. As ever I cannot praise enough, the artistry of the great John Williams. Once again, his score permeates every aspect of the film and is a living character, providing the emotional heart and soul of the proceedings. And as far as I’m concerned, whenever an actor from the classic trilogy was on screen, The Rise of Skywalker really hit its stride. Yes you can argue the Lando Calrissian was an underdeveloped character to begin with but Billy Dee Williams has a presence and a natural charisma. It was great to see him fly the Millennium Falcon one more time.
Although I will happily admit that The Rise of Skywalker is very entertaining and winds up the story suitably, I can’t help but feel I’ve been shamelessly manipulated; in the same way as watching a renown illusionist do a show at Las Vegas. It’s all great fun but you know that everything is a contrivance and a deliberate misdirection. Key cast members are sent to classic locations and iconic structures have conveniently survived catastrophic events. The story also feigns the death or imperils much loved characters, only to reveal these events to be bluffs later on. And too many of the major plot twists and turn just defy established lore for the sake of narrative convenience. I was often reminded while watching The Rise of Skywalker, of the classic Simpson’s episode “When You Dish Upon a Star” during which Homer pitches a movie screenplay about “"killer robot driving instructor that travels back in time for some reason". Every time something implausible, contradictory or convenient happens in The Rise of Skywalker, I would just think “for some reason” and it pretty much summed things up every time.
I suspect that for many Star Wars fans, the fundamental flaws inherent in The Rise of Skywalker will be outweighed by the cameos, homages and overall fan service that Disney have produced. I did just that and accepted the movie for what it is and broadly I enjoyed it. For example, exactly why Dominic Monaghan had such an obvious guest appearance, I’m not quite sure. But as C-3PO once said “It’s nice to see a familiar face”. As for the staggering crass expositionary dialogue that crops up from time to time, you have to remember that event movies such as this bring a lot of casual viewers and non-fans to the movie theatre. Plus the last instalment in any major, much beloved franchise is always a tough gig to undertake. However, there will be those who will not be at all pleased about this movie and I fully expect an internet outrage at some point soon. Once again, if a film is poorly made or under written, then these are legitimate grounds for criticism and complaint. If you’re peeved because a film didn’t pan out the way you wanted it to, then tough luck. Frankly it is good that the original Star Wars story arc has come to an end. Its broadly been a fun ride but the franchise has attained too much pop culture baggage. I personally think that the standalone movies about classic characters and scenarios are the way forward. I really like Rogue One and I’m currently enjoying The Mandalorian. As for classic Star Wars, I’ll settle for this ending on the understanding that it’s now time to part company.
