LOTRO: Bullroarer Update 30.3 and Legendary Item Conversion
Bullroarer Update 30.3 - Beta 3 is currently live on The Lord of the Rings Online test server. This latest build focuses on Brawler Class and New Legendary Item System. As a player whose primary character (a level cap Lore-master) has two Legendary Items that are currently “maxed out”, I have been very interested in the revisions that developer’s Standing Stone Games have been working on. However, having logged into the test server last night and tried the new system, I now have reservations regarding the current build and concerns regarding several issues associated with converting an existing LI to a new one. I will try to keep my thoughts on the matter as clear and as simple as possible because despite changes, the new LI system is still very arcane. The average LOTRO player who struggles with the intricacies of the current game mechanics may possibly find the revised process just as complex.
Therefore, before I commence my summary of what I see as being the key problems, I would strongly urge those players who are already au fait with the existing LI system to read the thread on this current test build, over on the official LOTRO forums. Many of the posts there are made by long time, experienced players who share similar concerns to mine. They have supplied lots of data and technical analysis to substantiate the perceived problems.
Upon logging into Bullroarer (after having copied my level cap Lore-master), I opened the Legendary Item window to find that my Lore-master staff (which was maxed out and imbued) was missing. This is a known bug in the build. Some crafted weapons do not register. So I then converted my First Age Lore-master book (again imbued and fully maxed out), using the handy button at the bottom right hand corner of the LI window. I received 66 Enhanced Runes (Lvl 121), 4800 Ancient Script, 240 Enhanced Runes (Lvl 121), 8 Fragmented Morgul Traceries. Now to cut a long story short, the new constituent parts provided, when applied to a new LI were not sufficient to create a replacement weapon of commensurate quality. I tried this and when I equipped the new weapon and compared my characters stats on a before and after basis, they were not the same. The drop was between 15% to 20% which is quite significant.
The main point of contention appears to be with the current conversion compensation. There have been examples of non-imbued level cap LIs yielding the same rewards as imbued maxed out FA LIs. This obviously needs to be addressed. Then there is the wider issue of compensation for existing items associated with the old LI system. Shards, empowerment scrolls, crystals, relic boxes, runes, legacy replacement scrolls, scrolls of combination, legacy replacement scrolls and the like. All of which will be rendered obsolete when this update launches. Players will expect something back in return for these, especially for items bought from the LOTRO store. And another point of contention is when is the optimal time to convert your existing LIs? When Update 30.3 officially launches on October 13th or will it be wiser to wait until after Fate of Gundabad expansion launches on November 10th when players have reached the new level cap?
There are two weeks left until the proposed launch of the New Legendary Item System. Naturally anything currently being beta tested can potentially be changed. However, SSG has a track record of not always fixing systems and mechanics in beta and often releases updates that are still flawed. I would also argue that this revised system for LIs is still convoluted and doesn’t lend itself to being easily understood. I worry that players are going to log into LOTRO to find that the new LI system does not provide them with a commensurate weapon compared to what they already have and that there may not be adequate compensation for obsolete items. Let us remember that LIs require a significant investment of time, resources and for some player money. The last thing SSG needs are players that feel that something has been taken away from them.
Therefore, let us hope that these issues are remedied in the next fortnight and that SSG takes onboard the feedback that players are currently giving them. If more time is required, then the launch of Update 30.3 needs to be pushed back. Risking a debacle that may even eclipse the one that happened in 2013 when the skills tree was introduced, is a foolish and unnecessary risk. Yet I cannot help but feel that SSG are blithely walking into yet another problem of their own making. In the meantime I am going to level some additional LIs in the remaining two weeks to create additional resources for a suitable new weapon. If I ultimately find myself in a situation where I am demonstrably “hobbled”, statistically speaking, by the coming changes and have to repeat the work that I’ve already done, then it may be time for LOTRO and I to part company. I’m sure I’m not the only person considering this.
